Results

Show: Test set | Custom selection

Lumen Stenosis
Averages measures and ranks
Averages measures and ranks
Ranks per stenosis category
Ranks per stenosis category
Ranks per research center Ranks per research center


Average lumen measures

MethodAutomaticTotaldicemsdHausdorffTotal
name success%rankmmrankmmrankrank
MinArea
Hui Tang
  41 -- -- -- -- -- -- --
Reference
  41 100.0 1.00 0.01 1.00 0.06 1.00 1.00
ObserverA
  41 95.1 2.66 0.10 2.68 0.65 2.80 2.71
ObserverB
  41 94.6 3.46 0.11 3.39 0.83 3.20 3.35
ObserverC
  41 94.4 3.61 0.12 3.39 0.97 4.02 3.67
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  41 91.8 6.73 0.18 6.05 1.52 5.63 6.14
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  41 90.2 7.32 0.34 7.80 3.45 7.39 7.50
GIMET
Krissian and García
  41 87.3 7.10 0.54 8.00 4.42 7.90 7.67
Hui Tang   41 88.9 8.24 0.38 8.66 3.88 8.61 8.50
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X 33 89.6 10.32 0.17 8.10 1.71 8.17 8.86

Anonymous
  41 89.2 8.88 0.59 10.59 11.26 11.07 10.18
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  41 83.5 11.07 0.74 11.00 10.10 11.15 11.07
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  41 82.9 11.44 0.75 11.44 9.15 10.90 11.26
media
Wong et al.
  41 77.5 11.98 1.10 12.51 10.66 11.22 11.90
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  41 80.9 12.39 0.82 12.29 10.30 11.29 11.99
RGC
Valencia et al.
  37 53.6 14.12 3.39 14.20 12.35 12.68 13.67

Average lumen ranks per stenosis category.

MethodAutomaticNone0-3030-5050-7070-100
name      
MinArea
Hui Tang
  -- -- -- -- --
Reference
  1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
ObserverA
  2.71 2.77 2.57 2.50 3.00
ObserverB
  3.79 3.40 3.52 3.12 2.92
ObserverC
  3.75 3.97 3.19 3.92 3.42
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  6.79 6.53 5.33 5.92 5.92
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  8.71 6.90 7.57 8.25 6.25
GIMET
Krissian and García
  8.88 6.93 7.33 7.00 8.33
Hui Tang   8.62 8.30 9.00 8.54 8.17
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X 8.67 7.60 7.95 10.62 9.67

Anonymous
  9.71 10.60 9.81 10.21 10.42
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  10.67 10.77 12.29 10.71 11.17
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  10.08 11.37 11.33 11.33 12.17
media
Wong et al.
  12.17 12.77 12.10 10.92 11.38
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  10.71 12.60 12.05 11.88 12.58
RGC
Valencia et al.
  13.71 13.47 14.52 13.54 13.25

Average lumen ranks per research center

MethodAutomaticErasmusMCHadassahLP
name    
MinArea
Hui Tang
  -- -- --
Reference
  1.00 1.00 1.00
ObserverA
  2.88 2.38 2.43
ObserverB
  3.06 3.86 3.95
ObserverC
  3.27 5.43 3.48
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  5.65 7.24 6.91
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  7.14 8.67 7.76
GIMET
Krissian and García
  7.09 8.14 9.43
Hui Tang   8.44 8.81 8.43
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X 8.95 8.38 9.00

Anonymous
  10.10 11.29 9.38
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  11.30 8.95 12.33
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  11.88 10.24 9.90
media
Wong et al.
  12.42 10.76 11.05
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  12.16 12.00 11.33
RGC
Valencia et al.
  13.68 13.14 14.14

Stenosis measures

MethodAutomaticTotaldiamareaBaselineTotal
name success%rank%rankdiam*area*lumens*rank
MinArea
Hui Tang
  41 19.2 4.07 15.7 3.73 200.0 200.0 41 3.90
Reference
  41 0 1.00 0 1.00 6.6 8.0 41 1.00
ObserverA
  41 3.4 2.27 2.9 2.20 6.7 8.2 41 2.23
ObserverB
  41 5.4 2.66 4.3 2.46 9.0 8.7 41 2.56
ObserverC
  41 5.7 2.85 5.0 2.88 11.2 10.3 41 2.87
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  41 -- -- -- -- 9.7 12.8 41 --
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  41 -- -- -- -- 25.5 22.1 41 --
GIMET
Krissian and García
  41 -- -- -- -- 14.3 19.8 41 --
Hui Tang   41 -- -- -- -- 32.3 29.8 41 --
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X 41 -- -- -- -- 16.7 16.5 33 --

Anonymous
  41 -- -- -- -- 23.0 17.5 41 --
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  41 -- -- -- -- 31.2 35.7 41 --
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  41 -- -- -- -- 24.5 29.4 41 --
media
Wong et al.
  41 31.4 4.71 25.2 4.78 27.8 27.5 41 4.74
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  41 17.0 3.95 16.9 4.17 30.0 31.4 41 4.06
RGC
Valencia et al.
  41 43.3 5.34 37.0 4.98 36.2 39.7 37 5.16

Average stenosis ranks per stenosis category

MethodAutomaticNone0-3030-5050-7070-100
name      
MinArea
Hui Tang
  1.63 4.20 4.79 4.50 4.44
Reference
  1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
ObserverA
  1.00 2.65 2.36 3.25 1.81
ObserverB
  1.00 2.80 3.36 3.13 2.56
ObserverC
  1.00 3.55 3.07 3.44 3.13
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  -- -- -- -- --
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  -- -- -- -- --
GIMET
Krissian and García
  -- -- -- -- --
Hui Tang   -- -- -- -- --
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X -- -- -- -- --

Anonymous
  -- -- -- -- --
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  -- -- -- -- --
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  -- -- -- -- --
media
Wong et al.
  1.38 5.35 5.64 5.75 5.56
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  1.50 4.95 5.21 5.44 3.13
RGC
Valencia et al.
  1.75 5.45 6.07 6.44 6.13

Average stenosis ranks per research center

MethodAutomaticErasmusMCHadassahLP
name    
MinArea
Hui Tang
  4.02 3.93 3.43
Reference
  1.00 1.00 1.00
ObserverA
  2.35 2.21 1.79
ObserverB
  2.76 2.00 2.36
ObserverC
  2.98 2.71 2.57
SCR_Gulsun_Tek
Gülsün and Tek
  -- -- --
DiceAtMinArea
Hui Tang
  -- -- --
GIMET
Krissian and García
  -- -- --
Hui Tang   -- -- --
Medisys
Cuisenaire
X -- -- --

Anonymous
  -- -- --
TubularAnisotropy
Mille et al.
  -- -- --
HUJI-CASMIP
Freiman et al.
  -- -- --
media
Wong et al.
  4.94 4.14 4.57
MARACAS
Zuluaga et al.
  4.15 3.64 4.14
RGC
Valencia et al.
  5.59 3.86 4.79




* The measures indicated with an asterix (*) or in italics are not determined by the participants, but are the result of applying a standardized algorithm by the framework. These measures are not used in the calculation of the ranks.